The cave-temple art came with the eastward spread of Buddhism, rooted in the Indian tradition of carving cave shrines and continuing the Gandharan imagery while gradually becoming Chinese. Cave-cutting flourished from the Sixteen Kingdoms through the Northern Dynasties: the Dunhuang Mogao Caves (begun 366) excel in murals and painted sculpture; the Yungang caves at Datong (from 460, the five Tanyao caves) carved Buddhas into the cliff, the largest seventeen metres high, joining Gandharan vigour with Northern Wei spirit; the Longmen caves at Luoyang (cut after the capital moved there in 493) are finely wrought with "clear bones and elegant figures," and the Tang Vairocana Buddha (675) at some seventeen metres has been called the "Mona Lisa of the East"; the Maijishan caves at Tianshui are famous for clay sculpture. Cave-cutting peaked from the Northern and Southern Dynasties to the Tang and declined under the Song. The caves unite architecture, sculpture, painting and calligraphy, a visual archive of Buddhism's sinicization: from Yungang's vigour to Longmen's elegance, from Western-Region drapery to Chinese dress, the localization of foreign art is plainly visible. With the manuscripts of the Dunhuang library cave they form the twin treasures of twentieth-century Dunhuang studies.